Pars Review
  • HOME
  • Match Previews
  • Match Reports
  • 5 Things We Learned
  • View From The Stands
  • Video Zone
  • Matchday Photos
  • Away Day Stadia
  • Throwback
  • Pars Review blog Archives 2016-2017
  • Blast From The Past

Hippolyte and hypocrisy

25/4/2017

29 Comments

 
Picture
Sean Murdoch clearly gets a hand to the ball before Myles Hippolyte dives to win the penalty. Photo: News Group Ltd
In the past hour, Falkirk winger Myles Hippolyte has been issued, and has accepted, a 2 game ban from the SFA Compliance Officer for diving in the Pars v Falkirk game on Saturday. This proves what we all knew, but does not help Dunfermline losing a crucial goal, and in the process being denied the chance to achieve a promotion play-off place. 
After the game, Falkirk manager Peter Houston refused to criticise his player. Losing 1-0 and without a serious effort on target, Hippolyte dived without making contact with Pars keeper Sean Murdoch, and was rewarded with a penalty kick which Falkirk equalised from. The Scotsman reported the incident as follows: 'Dunfermline Athletic were left fuming after Falkirk were awarded a penalty following an elborate dive from Myles Hippolyte, which involved a somersault. The Pars were leading 1-0 through a first half Nicky Clark goal when Hippolyte took a tumble in the box as Dunfermline goalkeeper dove at his feet to push the ball out for a corner. The incident was picked up by footage from Dunfermline who shared it on their official Twitter account. It shows Hippolyte spotting his opportunity, planting his foot beside Murdoch’s hand before springing forward then over.'
Instead of condemning his player, Houston merely said: "I didn't see it. But if the referee gives it, it's a penalty."
This is the same Houston who has a history of alleging refereeing corruption against his own team. In December 2016, after Dunfermline were awarded a penalty against Falkirk, Houston had this to say:
"The referee gave them a bit of help. How he can tell the ball hit our player on the hand, I don't know. I thought they needed a bit of help to get the goal and the referee was willing to do that."

So much for, "if the referee gives it, it's a penalty."
In October 2015, after a Rangers v Falkirk game, Houston accused referee John McKendrick of being influenced by the Rangers manager and coaches: “The Rangers manager and backroom staff were having a right pop at the referee going up the tunnel at half time about giving them nothing," said Houston. "He certainly gave them something in the second-half. You wonder if pressure like that has got to the referee. I don't know. I am totally aggrieved with the fact that he gave a foul against us when Tom Taiwo clearly won the ball and the man fell into him and went down. It was never a free-kick in a month of Sundays. It was not a foul. Shocking decision. It cost us the match, 100 per cent. For me the referee has cost us a couple of points today. I went into see him. He is reporting me to the association for my language." 
So much for, "if the referee gives it, it's a penalty."
Picture
Peter Houston
In October 2010, when manager of Dundee United, Houston had this to say about referee Dougie McDonald:
“He always awards penalties against us and could not point to the spot quickly enough. I don’t know what goes through his head, but it looked like he couldn’t get his finger pointing at the spot quickly enough when he awarded the penalty. I’ve seen it again on the monitor, and it was never a penalty. The referee’s performance today was below average. I need a more consistent performance than that from a referee."
So much for, "if the referee gives it, it's a penalty."
Meanwhile, in another incident involving his own team, Houston had this to say in May 2016 when referee Alan Muir failed to award Hibs a penalty against Falkirk in a promotion play-off semi final game. TV footage showed that a penalty should have been awarded. Houston said: “I didn’t see it.” (Sound familiar?).  He then trotted out that old cliche: “These decisions even themselves out over a season.” 
There is no honour in cheating, or in inventing conspiracy theories, as Peter Houston is on record doing. His denial of the Hippolyte dive reflects very badly on him and his club.
Finally - and this is particularly Falkirk fans who have read this blog this week, many of whom have been abusive, I want to make the following very clear:

I have no time for cheats: I would never want to see our club resort to such behaviour in order to win a game. Football should be won fairly, even if mistakes contribute towards a goal. Without fair play, the game is dead. ​
In October 2016, Joe Cardle was booked for diving in a Challenge Cup game against Queen's Park. Here's what Pars Review said about it:
"The first half's main incident was when Joe Cardle tried and failed to get a penalty by diving, only to be correctly yellow carded by referee Nick Walsh. It was an embarrassing dive, and a deserved yellow card. This has to stop." 
Diving has no place in football. Neither does hypocrisy. I would rather lose than win a game by cheating. 
29 Comments
GG Riva link
25/4/2017 16:04:41

A well researched and well written article. First class.

Reply
Pars Review
25/4/2017 18:04:10

Thank you - I had reservations about posting it due to the level of abuse I have received here in recent articles (most of the comments have been removed), and I anticipate more of the same today, sadly. I appreciate your comment.

Reply
fud
25/4/2017 16:09:20

you weren't getting into the play-offs anyway ya munter

Reply
FFC
25/4/2017 16:19:32

Mind n dinni greet ya Baw

Reply
Swings and Roundabouts
25/4/2017 16:20:54

Just ignoring the Dunfermline dive which was spotted during the game? Yeah Hippolyte was looking for a penalty but Hopkirk was also trying to fool the Ref

Reply
Gthing
25/4/2017 16:27:55

Dirty cheating six fingered falkirk

Reply
par skelper
25/4/2017 17:43:03

Reply
par skelper
25/4/2017 17:43:38

get it roond ye

FFC
25/4/2017 18:41:49

😴😴😴😴😴😴😴😴😴😴😴😴😴

Reply
Peter Houston link
25/4/2017 16:36:39

Deal with it, I own you!

Reply
Stu
25/4/2017 16:43:50

Doesn't matter who you support, diving is cheating and I was embarrassed to see it from my own team - no doubt about it. However the constant greeting I've seen over my news feed recently is stressing me out. It's as though pars fans are forgetting that one of their players also tried to con the referee and got booked. There is no difference apart from one was inside the box and one wasn't. Both cheats. Pot kettle. Yous were never getting in the play offs anyway so pipe down

Reply
dafc
26/4/2017 11:35:28

Had every chance of play off we have Morton this weekend and their last game is Dundee united...

Reply
Richard cadette
25/4/2017 16:52:47

it was town in the town of dunfermline, where a loyal supporter of falkirk lay dying, shot by a dunfermline gun, as he lay on the terraces dying... he turned to the crowd and he said....

oooh richard cadette oooh richard cadette, front roll into the back of the net ahhhhhhhh.

ps myles is my boy and he knows your all maggots

Reply
Parhater
25/4/2017 16:57:21

So will your player who dived be getting a 2 game ban?

Reply
Rufus
25/4/2017 17:34:37

Now this is all over will you apologise to the Falkirk fans for the names and language used against, them. I was saddened to read that we have come down to this level

Reply
Pars Review
25/4/2017 18:06:41

Are you serious?! I have a record of deleted replies from Falkirk fans that would shock you - personal threats and abuse! Don't expect any apology from me unless you know what I have had to put up with over the past few days.

Reply
Singhds1
25/4/2017 20:01:11

One senses you have a rather mighty chip on your shoulder. Have you seen a shrink yet?

Be objective and no one would complain you numpty!

par skelper
25/4/2017 17:35:44

stop yer moaning, fifing basterts the lot ae yees

Reply
Sir Jones
25/4/2017 17:59:46

Filth has no conscience.

Wheeeeeeeeey

Reply
Bairnagain
25/4/2017 18:26:59

You have far too much time on your hands. You got beat get over it!!

Reply
Houstie Hardcore
25/4/2017 18:41:16

You don't like cheating?? What about the Pars financial doping, 0p in the pound bring back any memories?? By your logic all your achievements (granted they fit on the back of a stamp)in the last 17 years should be expunged, never mind a penalty!

Oh and why was my last comment deleted on your "filth has no conscience" post?? Hardly abusive?

Reply
Stevie Laing
25/4/2017 22:07:00

Maybe if your post wasnt as bias and reeled of bad blood and hatred of Falkirk FC you wouldnt get such negative responses.Football is a passionate game.and i understand your dissapointment and anger however thats football...diving is every bit as bad as influencing the referees decisions and the Dunfermline players surrounded him time and time again in an attempt to do just that....this is also CHEATING.....dry your eyes and take it on the chin....Falkirk 2 Dunfermline 1 no amount of bleating will change that...im sure the ever so sporting Dunfermline players would have refused the kind offer of a penalty if the boot was on the other foot.....

Reply
Alec ffc
25/4/2017 23:35:19

Dunfermline r shit end of

Reply
Michael Coyne
25/4/2017 23:56:48

You realise here is photographic evidence of your keeper going into and through hippolytes legs, you realise that don't you.
Maybe if you even mentioned the negatives from the fife side, you know higginbottom losing the head and a player getting booked for simulation, then folk might not get quite so annoyed.

I get it.......we ALL get it.......you have got a hate on for housty something fierce but don't be a dick and pretend no pars manager in the annals of time has ever responded positively to a decision going their way and negatively to a decision going against him! After reading your diatribe of hate I really can't get the idea out of my head that somehow a scrotum has grown arms and learned how to type.
I would be angry if on the other side......sure. but its football. This ideallic vision that seems to have been painted showing no dunfermline player has ever cheated (bare in mind your player got booked for simulation in the very same game) is ridiculous.
Have dunfermlone never been on the good side of a refereeing decision? Get a grip man.

As for the ref being from falkirk so obviously a bairn.......are you mental? I am sure it's the same in dunfermline but it's a fairly small percentage of football fans in falkirk who actually support falkirk. Most (80 to 90%) are old firm.

Reply
Pars Review
26/4/2017 05:21:35

Did you read the last few lines of the article, re-Pars players diving?
Murdoch got to the ball first.
Thanks for the comments.

Reply
Michael coyne
26/4/2017 09:56:03

Am I disputing this fact? I know he got to the ball but he also got tangled up in hippolytes legs. However theatrical Myles reaction was there WAS contact. You have not said weather or not any pars manager has, past or present, reacted like Houston though. Are you honestly trying to say your manager always speaks the truth even if it does mean challenging all refereeing errors, even if it's in your favour? This is the most baffling issue from your article.


Also watched the highlights of many English prem games and I don't think I watched one game where there was no simulation. It is a horrible thing to say but it just seems to be part of the makeup of today's game.
I do think all instances of simulation have to dealt a red card as its the only way players will stop trying to get a cheap free kick or penalty as a yellow, as it stands, is not achieving the desired affect.
All simulation, and that especially stands when two players who are having a pop at each other slightly nudge and a player throws himself to ground like he has been stabbed in the head.......embarrassing.

I just want to say though that you seem to be singling out Houston for special criticism like he is the only manager in the land who acts this way.

Stupac
26/4/2017 11:43:18

Remember when your team went in to administration and you cheated businesses out of thousands of pounds.

Reply
William Fowler
26/4/2017 19:11:33

I can’t believe the ill informed, unthinking comments coming from some Falkirk supporters. I am with you all the way when you say that the game is totally meaningless if a match is won by cheating and this goes for any team including Dunfermline Athletic. I fervently hope that if any of Athletic’s players are guilty of diving then the management would publicly condemn it. It is up to the SFA to have a more determined policy to get cheating out of the game. Post match penalties for cheating should be much more severe, including the possible deduction of points for the cheating team and again this includes Dunfermline Athletic
As a postscript – all this talk about past cheats is meaningless we need to look for the future of professional football in Scotland.

Reply
ffc1876
27/4/2017 09:10:17

Get it right round ye ya absolute roaster.

Reply



Leave a Reply.

    Blog Archive
    Original blog created July 2015.
    Moved to current site July 2016.

    September 2017
    August 2017
    July 2017
    June 2017
    May 2017
    April 2017
    March 2017
    February 2017
    January 2017
    December 2016
    November 2016
    October 2016
    September 2016
    August 2016
    July 2016

Proudly powered by Weebly
  • HOME
  • Match Previews
  • Match Reports
  • 5 Things We Learned
  • View From The Stands
  • Video Zone
  • Matchday Photos
  • Away Day Stadia
  • Throwback
  • Pars Review blog Archives 2016-2017
  • Blast From The Past